Special Reserve

2019 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

Full-bodied and densely packed, this ripe version oozes with sappy black cherry and red currant, while generous singed garrigue, tobacco leaf and olive tapenade roam in the background. Gains shape and length through the vanilla-kissed finish, thanks to tangy acidity. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Petit Sirah, Carignan and Marselan. Drink now through 2030. 2,250 cases made, 150 cases imported. –KB

Wine Spectator November 2023

Special Reserve

2019 Israel Upper Galilee
94 Points

This deep garnet-colored wine has a bouquet of Luxardo cherry, black plum, lavender and a hint of smoke. Blackberry, raspberry, caramel, aniseed and crumbled sage leaf flavors are cloaked in opulent tannins that slowly peel away to reveal a vivid, fruit-filled finish. Kosher. Palm Bay International. Editors’ Choice. —M.D.

Wine Enthusiast December 2023

Special Reserve

2018 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

Elegant and balanced, with sweet vanilla, fresh tobacco and cracked pepper infusing a base of red cassis and plum. Savory acidity and a subtle sanguine undercurrent add good energy. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Petite Sirah, Carignan and Marselan. Kosher. Drink now through 2026. 1,100 cases made, 300 cases imported. From Israel.—J.M.

Wine Spectator September 2023

Special Reserve

2019 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

Elegant and balanced, with sweet vanilla, fresh tobacco and cracked pepper infusing a base of red cassis and plum. Savory acidity and a subtle sanguine undercurrent add good energy. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Petite Sirah, Carignan and Marselan. Kosher. Drink now through 2026. 1,100 cases made, 300 cases imported. — KB

Wine Spectator October 2022

Special Reserve

2018 Israel Upper Galilee
92 Points

This dark red-violet wine has aromas of cassis, blackberry and a touch of green bell pepper. It feels good in the mouth with plush tannins and flavors of black cherry, black currant, milk chocolate and violet and a bright finish. Kosher. Palm Bay International. —M.D

Wine Enthusiast August 2022

Special Reserve

2019 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

This medium straw colored wine has a bouquet of Bartlett pear and toasted hazelnut. It is smooth on the palate, with flavors of Granny Smith apple, apricot, almonds and oregano. Kosher. Palm Bay International. —M.D.

Wine Enthusiast August 2022

Special Reserve

2019 Israel Upper Galilee
92 Points

The 2019 Special Reserve red is a blend of 35% Cabernet Sauvignon, 35% Syrah, 12% Petit Sirah, 10% Carignan and the rest Marselan, all aged for 18 months in 50% new French oak. It comes in at 13.9% alcohol. Of the to-be-released wines in this report, this is the farthest out, not likely to hit the marketplace until February 2023. It has been bottled since May 2021, though, so it should certainly be showing some of its stuff. As expected, it is a bit tight. As it airs out, the tannins increase in power, but they are never too ferocious. You could drink this sooner if it were available, but if it were available, then I'd probably still recommend waiting until next year anyway for better results. So, it's a plus that the winery is aging it for you. The rest is lovely. The texture leans to silk more than velvet. There are red fruits in abundance and a juicy, fresh finish. The freshness here is a big plus. This becomes enlivening rather than ponderous. Overall, this seems right on its normal marks. What it can develop into remains to be seen. It certainly has upside potential. At some point, it will be time for a vertical here, but this won't be ready for such an exercise for a couple of years, at least. This bottling has gone through some style changes in terms of blends, but the newest style, which includes Carignan and Marselan, certainly has several vintages under its belt now. It's a nice success. -M.S.

Wine Advocate April 2022

Special Reserve

2018 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

Fragrant, with a supple texture encasing notes of white peach, honeysuckle and melon, infused with spice, vanilla and chamomile accents. Lovely and fresh. Kosher. Roussanne and Marsanne. From Israel. Drink now. 400 cases made, 100 cases imported.-G.S.

Wine Spectator November 2021

Special Reserve

2017 Israel Upper Galilee
94 Points

Dark ruby to the eye, this wine has aromas of black cherry, violet and gunpowder. The palate offers slightly drying tannins and flavors of ripe summer cherry, black currant, salted toffee, fennel pollen and a soft brambly note. The lingering finish is remarkably bright.

Editor's Choice Award
Wine Enthusiast June 2021
Platinum

Special Reserve

2018 Israel Upper Galilee
93 Points

The 2018 Special Reserve red is a blend of 38% Cabernet Sauvignon, 37% Syrah, 10% Petite Sirah, 10% Carignan and 5% Marselan all aged for 18 months in 50% new French oak. It comes in at 13.7% alcohol. This is really the only place in the lineup where the tannic edge might make you want to cellar this for a year or two. Though even here the tannins are not too hard—just give it some air. Still, this is where the winery pulls out the stops. As time has gone on, this bottling has become very elegant, always demonstrating finesse and focus. So, too, this year. The precision is impressive. It is tightly wound, and there is a promise that both complexity and more harmony will come if you cellar it for a few years. It will become far more expressive. Also bright and fresh, this should be a pleasure to drink with food. At the same time, it is much more intriguing than the rest of the lineup. It has the best structure and the longest finish. Overall, this looks super. Let's start here in evaluation, and we'll see where it goes in time.

Wine Advocate April 2021
Platinum

Special Reserve

2017 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

A generous and sinewy red with a firm structure enveloping the black currant, dark olive and bay leaf flavors that are decked out with anise, graphite and black tea details. Smoke and savory spice notes linger on the finish. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Petite Sirah, Carignan and Marselan. Kosher. Drink now through 2025.

Wine Spectator December 2020
Platinum

Special Reserve

2016 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

Well-crafted, with a smoky undertone detailing the currant and blackberry flavors, matched to cedar, herb and black tea accents. Full, integrated tannins offer support through the olive and bay leaf elements on the finish. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Petite Sirah, Carignan and Marselan. Drink now through 2024. 825 cases made, 50 cases imported. - G.S.

Wine Spectator Web Only - 2019
Platinum

Special Reserve

2016 Israel Upper Galilee
93 Points

Deep ruby in color, this wine has a bouquet of cherry and sage. A network of strong tannins and equally weighted acidity provides structure for flavors of blackberry, cassis, toffee and lemon sorbet. The rich, satisfying finish is punctuated by a surprisingly bright finale.

Wine Enthusiast September 2019
Platinum

Special Reserve

2016 Israel Upper Galilee
93 Points

A gorgeous Special Reserve, this shows off its superb mid-palate finesse, beautiful structure and a long finish. It is tightly wound and precise. The grape blend gives this some aromatic earthiness—maybe the Syrah most of all—but that is a nuance and an advantage. 

Wine Advocate April 30, 2019
Platinum

Special Reserve

2014 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

Full-bodied, featuring refined layers of dried cherry, currant and graphite, laced with sandalwood and mineral details. Well-structured, with full, supple tannins framing the hints of herb, milk chocolate and anise on the finish. 

Wine Spectator September 30, 2018
Platinum

Special Reserve

2015 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

The 2015 Special Reserve red is a blend of 30% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Syrah, 17% Petite Sirah, 13% Carignan and 10% Marselan, aged for 17 months in 60% new French oak. This wasn't the greatest vintage in Israel, but Recanati picked early, avoiding problems that arose, said winemaker Gil Shatsberg. They created a rather refined Special Reserve. It's not the biggest and richest this year, but it has a sophisticated feel to it. This has that old-school mid-palate finesse, silky texture and impeccable balance. The finish is long and complex, filled with hints of beef, herbs and cherries, all mingled together. It ends dry and serious. This is an understated food wine this year. Some will like it even more for that graceful demeanor.

Wine Advocate June 29, 2018
Platinum

Special Reserve

2016 Israel Upper Galilee
89 Points

The 2016 Special Reserve white is a blend of 60% Roussanne and 40% Marsanne, aged for six months in 30% new French oak. There's a tinge of oak on the back end, but it integrates fairly quickly and well this year, although it always affects the texture. Gentle, round and harmonious, it has reasonable but only average persistence on the finish. It coats the mouth rather nicely with that caressing texture, but it does at times seem a bit too sedate, granting that these grapes aren't exactly Arinto or Sauvignon Blanc in profile. This might do well with a little more time in the bottle to acquire a bit of complexity. This may be the year where I prefer the Marawi. That may actually make Recanati happy, in a way.

Wine Advocate June 29, 2018

Special Reserve

2014 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

This dark garnet colored wine has aromas of black cherry and a faint touch of green bell pepper. Sleek tannins coat the palate as flavors of black cherry, raspberry, smoke, black pepper and eucalyptus cavort towards a lasting, smoky finish.

Wine Enthusiast April 2018
Platinum

Special Reserve

2014 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

The 2014 Special Reserve red, set for release in September, is a blend of 30% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Syrah, 17% Petite Sirah, 13% Carignan and 10% Marselan, aged for 18 months in new French oak. It comes in at 14% alcohol. Of all of Recanati's wines, this is the one I expect to demonstrate, usually, the most upside potential. I'm not completely positive about this year, though. If anything, it is a bit too straightforward for the level, although the tannins are there. It has the most depth and power of the group, but not by a whole lot, while it generally lacks the brightness and personality of the Marselan and Carignan. Overall, this is still pretty good—so don't misunderstand—but it does need to show me a bit more in the cellar, acquiring some complexity and harmony as it goes along, to justify an uptick. At the moment, I'd probably pick the Carignan among the current releases as my favorite.

Wine Advocate June 30, 2017
Platinum

Special Reserve

2013 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

This deeply-colored wine has a bouquet of cherry, pomegranate and white chocolate. It has flavors of black cherry jam, anise, mocha and a touch of orange peel. Mouth-coating tannins provide a matrix for an interesting touch of spiciness that gives way to a final taste of pomegranate. Kosher. 

Wine Enthusiast October 2016
Platinum

Special Reserve

2013 Israel Upper Galilee
90 Points

Juicy and rich, with lots of red plum and raspberry flavors that feature fresh acidity. Licorice notes show midpalate, presenting a finish that has accents of milk chocolate and paprika. Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Marselan and Carignan. Kosher. Drink now through 2019. 1,900 cases made.  –KM

Wine Spectator September 30, 2016
Platinum

Special Reserve

2013 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

The 2013 Special Reserve red is a blend of 25% Cabernet Sauvignon, 30% Syrah, 21% Carignan, 19% Marselan and 5% Petite Sirah; aged for 18 months in new French barriques. It comes in at 14.3% alcohol. This might not be as attention-getting as in some years, but it shows beautifully, crisp and often seductive. It grew on me steadily while it was open. The initial softness is cut by the underlying freshness, and some earthiness in the background (the Syrah asserting itself?) cuts the initial, straightforward presentation. Restrained, just a bit understated and beautifully balanced, this drinks moderately well now, but it can still improve with cellaring. It should make a great food wine, easy to drink, possessed of a rather fresh feel and not a hair out of place. It may yet be entitled to an uptick.

Wine Advocate April 2016
Platinum

Special Reserve

2005 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

The 2005 Special Reserve is revisited this issue as part of our retrospective. Still beautiful and having acquired some complexity along the way, this intense Special Reserve has a serious backbone, but more concentration and lushness than the regular Reserves (the 2006s were also reviewed this issue). Still a bit tight, this is acquiring some complexity now. It is very impressive on opening, even exciting. It is a wine that will certainly make some think it is a Bordeaux in a blind tasting. That said, it did develop a bit of funk that constrained my enthusiasm just a bit. It has still held well. Approachable now, it may not quite be at peak and it has plenty of life left, easily deserving an extension of the drinking window.

Wine Advocate April 2016
Platinum

Special Reserve

2012 Israel Upper Galilee
91 Points

A nose of black cherry, violet and vanilla paves the way for a grown up melange of fruit and savory flavors that include raspberry, cassis, brambles and smoked meat. Long-lasting tannins coat the palate through a finish marked by notes of berries and smoke.

Wine Enthusiast April 2016
Platinum

Special Reserve

2011 Israel Upper Galilee
92 Points

Deep red-violet to the eye, this wine has a well-defined nose of blueberry pie and flint. There is a good mix of tart fruit and spice, with flavors of blueberry, cranberry, black pepper, anise and smoked meat cavorting amidst very soft tannins. The smooth finish is characterized by flavors of smoke and orange zest.

Editors' Choice Award
Wine Enthusiast September 2015
Platinum

Special Reserve

2013 Israel Upper Galilee
89 Points

Violet-red in the glass, this wine has fragrances of watermelon and black cherry. Tannins come on strong at first but are undercut by astringent notes of cranberry alongside flavors of cherry, pomegranate, vanilla and French toast.

Wine Enthusiast September 2015

Special Reserve

2011 Israel Upper Galilee
88 Points

A blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot with a small percentage of Petite Sirah and Syrah, this is earthy and gamey, the cinnamon and clove notes pointing it towards lamb shawarma for dinner.

Wine & Spirits August 2014

Special Reserve

2004 Israel Upper Galilee
89 Points

The 2004 Special Reserve is 92% Cabernet Sauvignon and the rest Merlot. This is a beautifully constructed wine, showing tannic pop and steely earthiness, but it does still have a significant green streak. Although that has calmed with age, it is obvious enough so that if the wine were served blind I might?ve guessed it was Cabernet Franc. The focus and bright acidity, though, would make it a lovely food wine ? and the right matchup will blend with the flavor medley, too, and mute that aspect of it...it has a nice, juicy finish that I liked more and more. Overall, I rather liked how this has developed. I haven?t changed my opinion of its limitations, but its structure is quite admirable and it should drink very well in the right circumstances. It should easily hold a few more years, but let?s be conservative and see if the fruit keeps pace with the structure. Drink now-2016.

Wine Advocate April 2013